|
Multiple Winners by Jockey/Trainer/Owner Historical Time Progression |
|
|
*Denotes Triple Crown Winner |
The Kentucky Derby was run at 1 1/2 Miles until 1896 |
| Year | Winner/Odds | Jockey | Trainer | Owner | Time | Place | Show | Favorite/Finish |
| 2007 | Street Sense (4.90) | Calvin Borel | Carl Nafzger | James B. Tafel | 2:02.17 | Hard Spun | Curlin | Street Sense (1st) |
| 2006 | Barbaro (6.10) | Edgar Prado | Michael R. Matz | Lael Stables | 2:01.36 | Bluegrass Cat | Steppenwolfer | Sweetnorthernsaint (7th) |
| 2005 | Giacomo (50.30) | Mike E. Smith | John Shireffs | Jerry & Ann Moss | 2:02.75 | Closing Argument | Afleet Alex | Bellamy Road (7th) |
| 2004 | Smarty Jones (4.10) | Stewart Elliott | John Servis | Someday Farm | 2:04.06 | Lion Heart | Imperialism | Smarty Jones (1st) |
| 2003 | Funny Cide (12.80) | Jose Santos | Barclay Tagg | Sackatoga Stable | 2:01.19 | Empire Maker | Peace Rules | Empire Maker (2nd) |
| 2002 | War Emblem (20.50) | Victor Espinoza | Bob Baffert | Thoroughbred Corp | 2:01.13 | Proud Citizen | Perfect Drift | Harlan's Holiday (7th) |
| 2001 | Monarchos (10.50) | Jorge F. Chavez | John T. Ward Jr. | John C. Oxley | 1:59.97 | Invisible Ink | Congaree | Point Given (5th) |
| 2000 | Fusaichi Pegasus (2.30) | Kent Desormeaux | Neil Drysdale | Fusao Sekiguchi | 2:01.00 | Aptitude | Impeachment | Fusaichi Pegasus (1st) |
| 1999 | Charismatic (31.30) | Chris Antley | D. Wayne Lukas | Bob & Beverly Lewis | 2:03.20 | Menifee | Cat Thief | Excellent Meeting/General Challenge (5th/11th) |
| 1998 | Real Quiet (8.40) | Kent Desormeuax | Bob Baffert | Michael E. Pegram | 2:02.20 | Victory Gallop | Indian Charlie | Indian Charlie (3rd) |
| 1997 | Silver Charm (4.00) | Gary Stevens | Bob Baffert | Bob & Beverly Lewis | 2:02.40 | Captain Bodgit | Free House | Captain Bodgit (2nd) |
| 1996 | Grindstone (5.90) | Jerry Bailey | D. Wayne Lukas | Overbrook Farm | 2:01.00 | Cavonnier | Prince of Thieves | Unbridled's Song (5th) |
| 1995 | Thunder Gulch (24.50) | Gary Stevens | D. Wayne Lukas | Michael Tabor | 2:01.20 | Tejano Run | Timber Country | Timber Country/Serena's Song (3rd/16th) |
| 1994 | Go For Gin (9.10) | Chris McCarron | Nick Zito | Condren & Cornacchia | 2:03.60 | Strodes Creek | Blumin Affair | Holy Bull (12th) |
| 1993 | Sea Hero (12.90) | Jerry Bailey | Mackenzie Miller | Rokeby Stables | 2:02.40 | Prairie Bayou | Wild Gale | Prairie Bayou (2nd) |
| 1992 | Lil E. Tee (16.80 | Pat Day | Lynn S. Whiting | W. Carl Partee | 2:03.00 | Casual Lies | Dance Floor | Arazi (8th) |
| 1991 | Strike The Gold (4.80) | Chris Antley | Nick Zito | BCC Stable | 2:03.00 | Best Pal | Mane Minister | Hansel (10th) |
| 1990 | Unbridled (10.80) | Craig Perret | Carl Nafzger | Frances A. Genter | 2:02.00 | Summer Squall | Pleasant Tap | Mister Frisky (8th) |
| 1989 | Sunday Silence (3.10) | Pat Valenzuela | Charlie Whittingham | H-G-W Partners | 2:05.00 | Easy Goer | Awe Inspiring | Easy Goer/Awe Inspiring (2nd/3rd) |
| 1988 | Winning Colors (3.40) | Gary Stevens | D. Wayne Lukas | Eugene V. Klein | 2:02.20 | Forty Niner | Risen Star | Winning Colors (1st) |
| 1987 | Alysheba (8.40) | Chris McCarron | Jack Van Berg | D. & P. Scharbauer | 2:03.40 | Bet Twice | Avies Copy | Demons Begone (17h) |
| 1986 | Ferdinand (17.70) | Bill Shoemaker | Charlie Whittingham | Elizabeth A. Keck | 2:02.80 | Bold Arrangement | Broad Bush | Snow Chief (11th) |
| 1985 | Spend A Buck (4.10) | Angel Cordero Jr. | Cam Gambolati | Hunter Farm | 2:00.20 | Stephan's Odyssey | Chief's Crown | Chief's Crown (3rd) |
| 1984 | Swale (3.40) | Laffit Pincay Jr. | Woody Stephens | Claiborne Farms | 2:02.40 | Coax Me Chad | At The Threshold | Life's Magic/Althea (8th/19th) |
| 1983 | Sunny's Halo (2.50) | Ed Delahoussaye | David C. Cross Jr. | D.J. Foster Stable | 2:02.20 | Desert Wine | Caveat | Marfa/Balboa Native/Total Departure (5th/9th/20th) |
| 1982 | Gato Del Sol (21.20) | Ed Delahoussaye | Edwin J. Gregson | Hancock & Peters | 2:02.40 | Laser Light | Reinvested | Air Forbes Won (7th) |
| 1981 | Pleasant Colony (3.50) | Jorge Velasquez | John P. Campo | Buckland Farm | 2:02.00 | Woodchopper | Partez | Proud Appeal/Golden Derby (18th/21st) |
| 1980 | Genuine Risk (13.30) | Jacinto Vasquez | LeRoy Jolley | Diana Firestone | 2:02.00 | Rumbo | Jaklin Klugman | Rockhill Native (5th) |
| 1979 | Spectacular Bid (.60) | Ronnie Franklin | Bud Delp | Hawksworth Farms | 2:02.40 | General Assembly | Golden Act | Spectacular Bid (1st) |
| 1978 | *Affirmed (1.80 | Steve Cauthen | Laz Berrera | Harbor View Farm | 2:01.20 | Alydar | Believe It | Alydar (2nd) |
| 1977 | *Seattle Slew (.50) | Jean Cruget | William H. Turner Jr. | Karen L. Taylor | 2:02.20 | Run Dusty Run | Sanhedrin | Seattle Slew (1st) |
| 1976 | Bold Forbes (3.00) | Angel Cordero, Jr. | Laz Berrera | E. Rodriguez Tizol | 2:01.60 | Honest Pleasure | Elocutionist | Honest Pleasure (2nd) |
| 1975 | Foolish Pleasure (1.90) | Jacinto Vasquez | LeRoy Jolley | John L. Greer | 2:02.00 | Avatar | Diabolo | Foolish Pleasure (1st) |
| 1974 | Cannonade (1.50) | Angel Cordero Jr. | Woody Stephens | John M. Olin | 2:04.00 | Hudson County | Agitate | Cannonade/Judger (1st/8th) |
| 1973 | *Secretariat (1.50) | Ron Turcotte | Lucien Laurin | Meadow Stable | 1:59.40 | Sham | Our Native | Secretariat/Angle Light (1st/10th) |
| 1972 | Riva Ridge (1.50) | Ron Turcotte | Lucien Laurin | Meadow Stable | 2:01.80 | No Le Hace | Hold Your Peace | Riva Ridge (1st) |
| 1971 | Canonero II (8.70) | Gustavo Avila | Juan Arias | Edgar Caibett | 2:03.20 | Jim French | Bold Reason | Unconscious (5th) |
| 1970 | Dust Commander (15.30) | Mike Manganello | Don Combs | Robert E. Lehman | 2:03.40 | My Dad George | High Echelon | My Dad George (2nd) |
| 1969 | Majestic Prince (1.40) | Bill Hartack | Johnny Longden | Frank McMahon | 2:01.80 | Arts and Letters | Dike | Majestic Prince (1st) |
| 1968 | Dancers Image(3.60) (DQ) | Bobby Ussery | Lou Calavaris, Jr. | Peter Fuller | 2:02.20 | Francie's Hat | T.V. Commercial | Forward Pass (1st) |
| Forward Pass (2.20) | Ismael Valenzuela | Henry Forrest | Calumet Farm | |||||
| 1967 | Proud Clarion (30.10) | Bobby Ussery | Lloyd Gentry, Jr. | Darby Dan Farm | 2:00.60 | Barbs Delight | Damascus | Damascus (3rd) |
| 1966 | Kauai King (2.40) | Don Brumfield | Henry Forrest | Ford Stable | 2:02.00 | Advocator | Blue Sky | Kauai King (1st) |
| 1965 | Lucky Debonair (4.30) | Bill Shoemaker | Frank Catrone | Ada L. Rice | 2:01.20 | Dapper Dan | Tom Rolfe | Bold Lad (10th) |
| 1964 | Northern Dancer (3.40) | Bill Hartack | Horatio Luro | Windfields Farm | 2:00.00 | Hill Rise | The Scoundrel | Hill Rise (2nd) |
| 1963 | Chateaugay (9.40) | Braulio Baeza | James P. Conway | Darby Dan Farm | 2:01.80 | Never Bend | Candy Spots | Candy Spots (3rd) |
| 1962 | Decidedly (8.70) | Bill Hartack | Horatio Luro | El Peco Ranch | 2:00.40 | Roman Line | Ridan | Ridan (3rd) |
| 1961 | Carry Back (2.50) | Johnny Sellers | Jack A. Price | Katherine Price | 2:04.00 | Crozier | Bass Clef | Carry Back (1st) |
| 1960 | Venetian Way (6.30) | Bill Hartack | Victor Sovinski | Sunny Blue Farm | 2:02.40 | Bally Ache | Victoria Park | Tompion (4th) |
| 1959 | Tomy Lee (3.70) | Bill Shoemaker | Frank Childs | Fred & Juliette Turner | 2:02.20 | Sword Dancer | First Landing | First Landing (3rd) |
| 1958 | Tim Tam (2.10) | Ismael Valenzuela | Jimmy Jones | Calumet Farm | 2:05.00 | Lincoln Road | Noureddin | Jewel's Reward (4th) |
| 1957 | Iron Liege (8.40) | Bill Hartack | Jimmy Jones | Calumet Farm | 2:02.20 | Gallant Man | Round Table | Bold Ruler (4th) |
| 1956 | Needles (1.60) | David Erb | Hugh L. Fontaine | D & H Stable | 2:03.40 | Fabius | Come On Red | Needles (1st) |
| 1955 | Swaps (2.80) | Bill Shoemaker | Mesh Tenney | Rex C. Ellsworth | 2:01.80 | Nashua | Summer Tan | Nashua (2nd) |
| 1954 | Determine (4.30) | Raymond York | William Molter | Andrew J. Crevolin | 2:03.00 | Hasty Road | Hasseyampa | Correlation (6th) |
| 1953 | Dark Star (24.90) | Hank Moreno | Eddie Hayward | Cain Hoy Stable | 2:02.00 | Native Dancer | Invigorator | Native Dancer (2nd) |
| 1952 | Hill Gail (1.10) | Eddie Arcaro | Ben A. Jones | Calumet Farm | 2:01.60 | Sub Fleet | Blue Man | Hill Gail (1st) |
| 1951 | Count Turf (14.60) | Conn McCreary | Sol Rutchick | Jack J. Amiel | 2:02.60 | Royal Mustang | Ruhe | Battle Morn (6th) |
| 1950 | Middleground (7.90) | William Boland | Max Hirsch | King Ranch | 2:01.60 | Hill Prince | Mr. Trouble | Your Host (9th) |
| 1949 | Ponder (16.00) | Steve Brooks | Ben A. Jones | Calumet Farm | 2:04.20 | Capot | Palestinian | Olympia (6th) |
| 1948 | *Citation (.40) | Eddie Arcaro | Ben A. Jones | Calumet Farm | 2:05.40 | Coaltown | My Request | Citation/Coaltown (1st/2nd) |
| 1947 | Jet Pilot (5.40) | Eric Guerin | Tom Smith | Maine Chance Farm | 2:06.80 | Phalanx | Faultless | Phalanx (2nd) |
| 1946 | *Assault (8.20) | Warren Mehrtens | Max Hirsch | King Ranch | 2:06.60 | Spy Song | Hampden | Lord Boswell/Knockdown/Perfect Bahram (4th, 5th, 9th) |
| 1945 | Hoop Jr (3.70) | Eddie Arcaro | Ivan Parke | Fred W. Hooper | 2:07.00 | Pot o’ Luck | Darby Dieppe | Pot o’ Luck (2nd) |
| 1944 | Pensive (7.10) | Conn McCreary | Ben A. Jones | Calumet Farm | 2:04.20 | Broadcloth | Stir Up | Stir Up (3rd) |
| 1943 | *Count Fleet (.40) | Johnny Longden | G. Donald Cameron | Fannie Hertz | 2:04.00 | Blue Swords | Slide Rule | Count Fleet (1st) |
| 1942 | Shut Out (1.90) | Wayne Wright | John M. Gaver, Sr. | Greentree Stable | 2:04.40 | Alsab | Valdina Orphan | Shut Out/Devil Diver (1st/6th) |
| 1941 | *Whirlaway (2.90) | Eddie Arcaro | Ben A. Jones | Calumet Farm | 2:01.40 | Staretor | Market Wise | Whirlaway (1st) |
| 1940 | Gallahadion (35.20) | Carroll Bierman | Roy Waldron | Milky Way Farm | 2:05.00 | Bimelech | Dit | Bimelech (2nd) |
| 1939 | Johnstown (.60) | James Stout | Jim Fitzsimmons | Belair Stud | 2:03.40 | Challedon | Heather Broom | Johnstown (1st) |
| 1938 | Lawrin (8.60) | Eddie Arcaro | Ben A. Jones | Herbert M. Woolf | 2:04.80 | Dauber | Can't Wait | Fighting Fox (6th) |
| 1937 | *War Admiral (1.60) | Charley Kurtsinger | George Conway | Glen Riddle Farm | 2:03.20 | Pompoon | Reaping Reward | War Admiral (1st) |
| 1936 | Bold Venture (20.50) | Ira Hanford | Max Hirsch | Morton L. Schwartz | 2:03.60 | Brevity | Indian Broom | Brevity (2nd) |
| 1935 | *Omaha (4.00) | Willie Saunders | Jim Fitzsimmons | Belair Stud | 2:05.00 | Roman Soldier | Whiskolo | Nellie Flag (4th) |
| 1934 | Cavalcade (1.50) | Mack Garner | Bob Smith | Brookmeade Stable | 2:04.00 | Discovery | Agrarian | Cavalcade/Time Clock (1st/7th) |
| 1933 | Brokers Tip (8.93) | Don Meade | Herbert J. Thompson | Edward R. Bradley | 2:06.80 | Head Play | Charley O. | Mr. Khayyam/Good Advice (8th/DNF) |
| 1932 | Burgoo King (5.62) | Eugene James | Herbert J. Thompson | Edward R. Bradley | 2:05.20 | Economic | Stepenfetchit | Tick On (6th) |
| 1931 | Twenty Grand (.88) | Charley Kurtsinger | James G. Rowe, Jr. | Greentree Stable | 2:01.80 | Sweep All | Mate | Twenty Grand/Anchors Aweigh/Surf Board (1st,10th,11th) |
| 1930 | *Gallant Fox (1.19) | Earl Sande | Jim Fitzsimmons | Belair Stud | 2:07.60 | Gallant Knight | Ned O. | Gallant Fox (1st) |
| 1929 | Clyde Van Dusen (3.00) | Linus McAtee | Clyde Van Dusen | H. P. Gardner | 2:10.80 | Naishapur | Panchio | Blue Larkspur/Bay Beauty (4th/13th) |
| 1928 | Reigh Count (2.06) | Chick Lang | Bert S. Michell | Fannie Hertz | 2:10.40 | Misstep | Toro | Reigh Count/Reigh Olga (1st/5th) |
| 1927 | Whiskery (2.40) | Linus McAtee | Fred Hopkins | Harry P. Whitney | 2:06.00 | Osmand | Jock | Whiskery/Bostonian (1st/5th) |
| 1926 | Bubbling Over (1.90) | Albert Johnson | Herbert J. Thompson | Edward R. Bradley | 2:03.80 | Bagenbaggage | Rock Man | Bubbling Over/Bagenbaggage (1st/2nd) |
| 1925 | Flying Ebony (3.15) | Earl Sande | William B. Duke | Clifford A. Cochran | 2:07.60 | Captain Hal | Son of John | Quatrain (12th) |
| 1924 | Black Gold (1.75) | John D. Mooney | Hanley Webb | Rosa M. Hoots | 2:05.20 | Chilhowee | Beau Butler | Black Gold (1st) |
| 1923 | Zev (19.20) | Earl Sande | David J. Leary | Rancocas Stable | 2:05.40 | Martingale | Virgil | Enchantment/Rialto/Picketer/Cherry Pie (5th,6th,15th,20th) |
| 1922 | Morvich (1.20) | Albert Johnson | Fred Burlew | Benjamin Block | 2:04.60 | Bet Mosie | John Finn | Morvich (1st) |
| 1921 | Behave Yourself (8.65) | Charles Thompson | Herbert J. Thompson | Edward R. Bradley | 2:04.20 | Black Servant | Prudery | Prudery/Tryster (3rd/4th) |
| 1920 | Paul Jones (16.20) | Ted Rice | Billy Garth | Ral Parr | 2:09.00 | Upset | On Watch | Upset/Damask/Wildair (2nd,4th,8th) |
| 1919 | *Sir Barton (2.60) | Johnny Loftus | H. Guy Bedwell | J. K. L. Ross | 2:09.80 | Billy Kelly | Under Fire | Sailor/Eternal (7th/10th) |
| 1918 | Exterminator (29.60) | William Knapp | Henry McDaniel | Willis Sharpe Kilmer | 2:10.80 | Escoba | Viva America | War Cloud (4th) |
| 1917 | Omar Khayyam (12.80) | Charles Borel | Charles T. Patterson | Billings & Johnson | 2:04.60 | Ticket | Midway | Ticker (2nd) |
| 1916 | George Smith (4.15) | Johnny Loftus | Hollie Hughes | John Sanford | 2:04.00 | Star Hawk | Franklin | Thunderer/Dominant (5th/7th) |
| 1915 | Regret (2.65) | Joe Notter | James G. Rowe, Sr. | Harry P. Whitney | 2:05.40 | Pebbles I | Sharpshooter | Regret (1st) |
| 1914 | Old Rosebud (.85) | John McCabe | Frank D. Weir | H. C. Applegate | 2:03.40 | Hodge | Bronzewing | Old Rosebud (1st) |
| 1913 | Donerail (91.45) | Roscoe Goose | Thomas P. Hayes | Thomas P. Hayes | 2:04.80 | Ten Point | Gowell | Ten Point (2nd) |
| 1912 | Worth (.80) | Carroll H. Shilling | Frank M. Taylor | H. C. Hallenbeck | 2:09.40 | Duval | Flamma | Worth (1st) |
| 1911 | Meridian (2.90) | George Archibald | Albert Ewing | R. F. Carman | 2:05.00 | Governor Gray | Colston | Governor Gray (2nd) |
| 1910 | Donau (1.65) | Fred Herbert | George Ham | William Gerst | 2:06.40 | Joe Morris | Fighting Bob | Donau (1st) |
| 1909 | Wintergreen (1.96) | Vincent Powers | Charles Mack | Jerome B. Respess | 2:08.20 | Miami | Dr. Barkley | Wintergreen (1st) |
| 1908 | Stone Street (23.72) | Arthur Pickens | J. W. Hall | C. E. & J. W. Hamilton | 2:15.20 | Sir Cleges | Dunvegan | Sir Cleges (2nd) |
| 1907 | Pink Star (15.00) | Andy Minder | W. H. Fizer | J. Hal Woodford | 2:12.60 | Zal | Ovelando | Red Gauntlet (4th) |
| 1906 | Sir Huon (1.10) | Roscoe Troxler | Pete Coyne | Bashford Manor Stable | 2:08.80 | Lady Navarre | James Reddick | Sir Huon (1st) |
| 1905 | Agile (.33) | Jack Martin | Robert Tucker | Sam S. Brown | 2:10.75 | Ram’s Horn | Layson | Agile (1st) |
| 1904 | Elwood (15.00) | Shorty Prior | Charles E. Durnell | Mrs. C. E. Durnell | 2:08.50 | Ed Tierney | Brancas | Proceeds (5th) |
| 1903 | Judge Himes (10.00) | Hal Booker | John P. Mayberry | Charles R. Ellison | 2:09.00 | Early | Bourbon | Early (2nd) |
| 1902 | Alan-a-Dale (1.50) | Jimmy Winkfield | Tom C. McDowell | Tom C. McDowell | 2:08.75 | Inventor | The Rival | Abe Frank (4th) |
| 1901 | His Eminence (3.00) | Jimmy Winkfield | Frank B. Van Meter | Frank B. Van Meter | 2:07.75 | Sannazarro | Driscoll | Alard Scheck (5th) |
| 1900 | Lieut. Gibson (.70) | Jimmy Boland | Charles Hughes | Charles H. Smith | 2:06.25 | Florizar | Thrive | Lieut. Gibson (1st) |
| 1899 | Manuel (.55) | Fred Taral | Robert J. Walden | A. H. & D. H. Morris | 2:12.00 | Corsini | Mazo | Manuel (1st) |
| 1898 | Plaudit (3.00) | Willie Simms | John E. Madden | John E. Madden | 2:09.00 | Lieber Karl | Isabey | Lieber Karl (2nd) |
| 1897 | Typhoon II (3.00) | Buttons Garner | J. C. Cahn | J. C. Cahn | 2:12.50 | Ornament | Dr. Catlett | Ornament (2nd) |
| 1896 | Ben Brush (.50) | Willie Simms | Hardy Campbell | Mike F. Dwyer | 2:07.75 | Ben Eder | Semper Ego | Ben Brush (1st) |
| 1895 | Halma (.33) | Soup Perkins | Byron McClelland | Byron McClelland | 2:37.50 | Basso | Laureate | Halma (1st) |
| 1894 | Chant (.40) | Frank Goodale | H. Eugene Leigh | Leigh & Rose | 2:41.00 | Pearl Song | Sigurd | Chant (1st) |
| 1893 | Lookout (.70) | Eddie Kunze | William McDaniel | Cushing & Orth | 2:39.25 | Plutus | Boundless | Lookout/Boundless (1st/3rd) |
| 1892 | Azra (1.50) | Lonnie Clayton | John Morris | Bashford Manor Stable | 2:41.50 | Huron | Phil Dwyer | Huron/Phil Dwyer (2nd/3rd) |
| 1891 | Kingman (.50) | Isaac Murphy | Dud Allen | Jacobin Stable | 2:52.25 | Balgowan | High Tariff | Kingman (1st) |
| 1890 | Riley (4.00) | Isaac Murphy | Edward Corrigan | Edward Corrigan | 2:45.00 | Bill Letcher | Robespierre | Robespierre (3rd) |
| 1889 | Spokane (6.00) | Thomas Kiley | John Rodegap | Noah Armstrong | 2:34.50 | Proctor Knott | Once Again | Proctor Knott (2nd) |
| 1888 | Macbeth II (6.00) | George Covington | John Campbell | Chicago Stable | 2:38.00 | Gallifet | White | Gallifet/Alexandria (2nd/4th) |
| 1887 | Montrose (10.00) | Isaac Lewis | John McGinty | Labold Brothers | 2:39.25 | Jim Gore | Jacobin | Banburg (4th) |
| 1886 | Ben Ali (1.72) | Paul Duffy | Jim Murphy | J. B. A. Haggin | 2:36.50 | Blue Wing | Free Knight | Ben Ali (1st) |
| 1885 | Joe Cotton (1.00) | Babe Henderson | Alex Perry | J. T. Williams | 2:37.25 | Bersan | Ten Booker | Joe Cotton (1st) |
| 1884 | Buchanan (3.00) | Isaac Murphy | William Bird | William Cottrill | 2:40.25 | Loftin | Audrain | Buchanan/Bob Miles (1st/4th) |
| 1883 | Leonatus (9-5) | Billy Donohue | Raleigh Colston | Chinn & Morgan | 2:43.00 | Drake Carter | Lord Raglan | Leonatus |
| 1882 | Apollo (10-1) | Babe Hurd | Green B. Morris | Morris & Patton | 2:40.00 | Runnymede | Bengal | Runnymede (2nd) |
| 1881 | Hindoo (1-3) | Jim McLaughlin | James G. Rowe, Sr. | Dwyer Bros. Stable | 2:40.00 | Lelex | Alfambra | Hindoo |
| 1880 | Fonso (7-1) | George Lewis | Tice Hutsell | J. Snell Shawhan | 2:37.50 | Kimball | Bancroft | Kimball (2nd) |
| 1879 | Lord Murphy (11-10) | Charlie Shauer | George Rice | Darden & Co | 2:37.00 | Falsetto | Strathmore | Lord Murphy |
| 1878 | Day Star (3-1) | Jimmy Carter | Lee Paul | T. J. Nichols | 2:37.25 | Himyar | Leveler | Himyar |
| 1877 | Baden-Baden | Billy Walker | Edward D. Brown | Daniel Swigert | 2:38.00 | Leonard | King William | Baden-Baden |
| 1876 | Vagrant (9-5) | Bobby Swim | James Williams | William Astor, Jr. | 2:38.25 | Creedmore | Harry Hill | Vagrant |
| 1875 | Aristides (2-1) | Oliver Lewis | Ansel Williamson | Hal P. McGrath | 2:37.75 | Volcano | Verdigris | Searcher (9th) |